Legislating the War on Terror

A Brookings Institution Press and the Hoover Institution and the Georgetown Center on National Security and the Law publicationThe events of September 11 and subsequent American actions irrevocably changed the political, military, and legal landscapes of U.S. national security. Predictably, many of the changes were controversial, and abuses were revealed. The United States needs a legal framework that reflects these new realities. Legislating the War on Terror presents an agenda for reforming the statutory law governing this new battle, balancing the need for security, the rule of law, and the constitutional rights that protect American freedom.The authors span a considerable swath of the political spectrum, but they all believe that Congress has a significant role to play in shaping the contours of America's confrontation with terrorism. Their essays are organized around the major tools that the United States has deployed against al Qaeda as well as the legal problems that have arisen as a result. Mark Gitenstein compares U.S. and foreign legal standards for detention, interrogation, and surveillance. Matthew Waxman studies possible strategic purposes for detaining people without charging them, while Jack Goldsmith imagines a system of judicially reviewed law-of-war detention. Robert Chesney suggests ways to refine U.S. criminal law into a more powerful instrument against terrorism. Robert Litt and Wells C. Bennett suggest the creation of a specialized bar of defense lawyers for trying accused terrorists in criminal courts. David Martin explores the relationship between immigration law and counterterrorism. David Kris lays out his proposals for modernizing the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. Justin Florence and Matthew Gerke outline possible reforms of civil justice procedures in national security litigation. Benjamin Wittes and Stuart Taylor Jr. investigate ways to improve interrogation laws while clarifying the definition and limits of torture. Kenneth Anderson argues for the protection of